Is Red Tractor High Welfare?

When it comes to buying pork, the Red Tractor label does not offer any assurance that the pigs were raised in high welfare conditions. The Red Tractor label is not a high welfare label and means you are likely to be buying pork from pigs that have suffered acutely from close confinement, lack of bedding, overcrowding and stress. However, it is important to remember that more than 80% of all UK pig farms use the Red Tractor label. If the Red Tractor label is used in conjunction with another higher welfare label (which is often the case), then the pig welfare standards will be raised to that label. But, if the Red Tractor label is the only welfare label on a pork product, it should be avoided for the following reasons…

1. Substandard Inspections

Red Tractor is managed by the limited company Assured Food Standards (AFS) which is owned and funded by the British farming and food industry. Approval by Red Tractor is the farming and food industry essentially marking its own homework. We need independent labelling and inspections to ensure high standards.

Red Tractor farms have frequently been exposed by campaigners showing the brutal conditions covered by the BBC, the Ecologist, the Times, the Daily Mail and Viva! to name a few. Occasionally when a farm is investigated and exposed, Red Tractor will withdraw accreditation, but for the most part they turn a blind eye, allowing farms to operate below minimum legal welfare standards. Red Tractor inspects farms once a year, but only one in a thousand inspections are unannounced.

2. Spreading Misinformation

Red Tractor spends a lot of money on clever advertising that is designed to make people think the welfare standards are higher than the reality. They’ve even been caught in the past deliberately and blatantly misleading people. One advert that read: “RED TRACTOR PORK IS HIGH WELFARE PORK” was ruled misleading by the Advertising Standards Authority and had to be removed.

3. Pigs in Cages

Under the Red Tractor label, mother pigs can be kept in steel cages too narrow for them to turn around for five weeks at a time during each pregnancy (equivalent to 2.5 months a year). Compassion in World Farming, the Soil Association and many other animal welfare charities continuously object to this cruelty, and urge the UK to follow other countries such as Norway, Finland and Switzerland that have already banned this inhumane, restricting and painful confinement.

4. Barren Floors

The Red Tractor label does not guarantee compliance with minimum UK legal welfare requirements. Many farms accredited by Red Tractor can house pigs permanently on bare concrete slats. This makes it impossible for the farm to comply with the UK law that requires pigs to have permanent access to straw or similar bedding.

5. Routine Mutilation

Many Red Tractor pig farms also ignore the law forbidding routine docking of piglets’ tails. The law specifies that tail docking cannot be carried out routinely, and that the cause of tail biting (stress caused by lack of bedding and overcrowding) must be addressed before any tail docking is carried out. However, it is clear that the routine tail docking of pigs is widespread and ongoing.

The Solution?

Watch out for pork products that only display the Red Tractor label… and don’t buy them. Use our pork labelling guide to find out more. You can find pork with high welfare labels in most supermarkets, such as *RSPCA Assured, Free Range or best of all Organic. These pigs will have been raised on high welfare farms, almost certainly in the UK. You can also ask for high welfare at your local butcher, or better still shop at your local farmers’ market, find high welfare online, or join a box scheme. If you’re eating out, always ask if the meat is from a high welfare farm.

Pork Labelling Guide

How Does Red Tractor Compare?

(tap/hover icons for more information)

Key Welfare Indicator Organic Free Range RSPCA + Outdoor Reared/Bred RSPCA Assured Outdoor Reared Outdoor Bred Red Tractor UK Standard EU Standard
Pigs Outdoors
No Cages
Adequate Straw/Bedding
No Tail Docking
No Antibiotics Overuse

Share This Article

Related ArticlesView all

September 11th, 2020
Anaerobic Digesters Facilitating UK Factory Farm Expansion

Malcolm McAllister, CEO of Farm Renewables UK, paints a rosy picture of the anaerobic digester (AD) plants which his company… Read More

August 27th, 2020
Cruel Farmers or a Cruel System?

The horror story experienced by US pig farmers who, between May and September, will have cruelly euthanized 10 million pigs,… Read More

July 23rd, 2020
Tory MPs Vote Against Their Own Access to Secret US Trade Talks

In the House of Commons debate on Monday 20th of July, the Tory majority marched on with their free-trade agenda… Read More

July 9th, 2020
#SaveBritishFarming London March

Yesterday, farmers and activists gathered in London to protest the real prospect of sub-standard imports from the US that would… Read More

July 7th, 2020
Farm Case Study 13: Farmer’s Choice, Hampshire

Jason from Farmer’s Choice Free Range in the South Downs says COVID-19 caused an increased demand that was driven both… Read More

July 1st, 2020
Producer Case Study 12: Primal Cut

Primal Cut are artisan producers that follow Slow Food principles. They promote local food & traditional cooking with free range,… Read More

Comments

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*
*